Michael's mundane days come to an end when he meets his maybe-gay, maybe-straight gym crush in the most unexpected way. Despite an inauspicious introduction, he and Tyler connect quickly. Michael's BFF Elise helps him learn a bit more about Tyler and start a conversation, but his sexuality is still a question. A budding friendship ensues as Michael struggles over when, and how, to come out to Tyler. When he slides it into a conversation, he's underwhelmed by Tyler's noncommittal reaction. Luckily, he doesn't have to wait long. An unexpected kiss opens the door to a conversation where Michael gets the news he wants. Prone to disaster, Michael inadvertently disrupts Tyler's life over and over again. Will the chaos and drama Michael creates drive Tyler away? Or will Michael's fumbling endear him to Tyler?