Perpetually single and unlucky in love, Nathan is in his mid-thirties with no romantic prospects to be seen. According to his best friend Kat, he lets go of guys too easily and doesn't fight for relationships to work. In a final act of desperation to meet someone, Nathan begrudgingly signs up for a class at the local community center. He hoped to take Beginner Spanish, but the class was full, and Nathan finds himself in a drab pottery class with a strict teacher. However, Nathan's luck changes when he meets Eduardo, a fellow student. He can barely keep his eyes off Eduardo, a man his age who is handsome, charming, and, most importantly, has an empty ring finger. After a flirty conversation after class, Nathan and Eduardo connect over their mutual desire to learn Spanish. They soon ditch the pottery class like mischievous school boys. Sharing a magical kiss makes Nathan's heart flutter as he wonders if Eduardo is the one he's been waiting for. When Eduardo meets Nathan's friends, he fits right in. Nathan can't believe how well their relationship is going. That is, until Eduardo seems to be holding back and hiding something. When the reason for Eduardo's secretive behavior is accidentally revealed, Nathan is left reeling. Will Eduardo's trust issues ruin everything he and Nathan have built together? Is a relationship with Eduardo worth fighting for?