A reunion of friends leads Clevelly to a magical revelation. Rudy makes a surprise visit to an old friend Casey. Rudy and his friends Nic and Jack haven't seen Casey since he and Jared admitted their love. But all doesn't go smoothly. A misunderstanding by Jared needs addressing, and Rudy's just the one to put things straight. At the offer of attending reindeer games with Rudy, and seeing Nic and Jack again, the couple quickly agree, and Jared arranges to be met at the airport by his cousin Clevelly. When Rudy meets Clevelly, he immediately recognizes the man as his mate. But since Rudy is a reindeer shifter and Clevelly is human, courtship proceeds slowly. When danger strikes, will Clevelly accept Rudy for who, and what he is, will he don Rudolph's reins?